This Will Make Some of You Even More Bonkers-Paul & Gaga
-
Lady Gaga was superb. I was really hoping and dreaming for Sir Paul to play the piano for "Glory". A girl can dream can't she ?
-
I appreciate the link ..... She did a really good version of it This saves me a lot of time in having to sift through much of the crap of the Oscar people and their attitudes .... I just stay away and catch any highlights ..... if there are any. I would pick Lady Gaga over his get together with Kayne .... I cringed when I heard that and hoped it was not true ....Lady Gaga at least has some music talent.
-
Compared to the other shake and bake Bozos. Gaga has talent. She is a MUSICIAN who can SING.
-
Lady Gaga is one of the few contemporary artists who could give a live version of 'Maybe I'm Amazed' justice.
-
moptops:
Compared to the other shake and bake Bozos. Gaga has talent. She is a MUSICIAN who can SING.
Rhianna is a talented singer IMHO.
-
I find it difficult to think of Lady Gaga as a musician. For me she is a singer and artist - showbiz. I would have said the same about Madonna, Tom Jones, Justin Bieber, Michael Jackson, Rihanna.... Michael Jackson and Madonn also wrote some memorable songs.... Paul McCartney I think of as Songwriter, composer, first and foremost... then singer and musician or multi-instrumentalist. A Musician to me I think is someone like Miles Davis, Ravi Shankar, Robert Fripp, Thelonius Monk, Charlie Parker, Robert Wyatt, Rick Wakeman... well, the categories goes on and on and cross over... I'll stop here.
-
Hendrix Ibsen:
I find it difficult to think of Lady Gaga as a musician. For me she is a singer and artist - showbiz. I would have said the same about Madonna, Tom Jones, Justin Bieber, Michael Jackson, Rihanna.... Michael Jackson and Madonn also wrote some memorable songs.... Paul McCartney I think of as Songwriter, composer, first and foremost... then singer and musician or multi-instrumentalist. A Musician to me I think is someone like Miles Davis, Ravi Shankar, Robert Fripp, Thelonius Monk, Charlie Parker, Robert Wyatt, Rick Wakeman... well, the categories goes on and on and cross over... I'll stop here.
Yes a composer first and foremost!
-
^^ I agree with the exception that not only can Lady Gaga sing, but she plays the piano like nobody's business. She has a great, and beautiful voice. Being able to play the piano means she is a musician, which sets her apart from the other artists above, except Paul. I really was so thrilled with her performance last night. She is lovely.
-
Hendrix Ibsen:
I find it difficult to think of Lady Gaga as a musician. For me she is a singer and artist - showbiz. I would have said the same about Madonna, Tom Jones, Justin Bieber, Michael Jackson, Rihanna.... Michael Jackson and Madonn also wrote some memorable songs.... Paul McCartney I think of as Songwriter, composer, first and foremost... then singer and musician or multi-instrumentalist. A Musician to me I think is someone like Miles Davis, Ravi Shankar, Robert Fripp, Thelonius Monk, Charlie Parker, Robert Wyatt, Rick Wakeman... well, the categories goes on and on and cross over... I'll stop here.
Singer, songwriter, composer, multi-instrumentalist...all are musicians.
-
hey_kittay:
^^ I agree with the exception that not only can Lady Gaga sing, but she plays the piano like nobody's business. She has a great, and beautiful voice. Being able to play the piano means she is a musician, which sets her apart from the other artists above, except Paul. I really was so thrilled with her performance last night. She is lovely.
Yes, I agree. I think GaGa is a classically trained pianist.
-
beatlesfanrandy:
Hendrix Ibsen:
I find it difficult to think of Lady Gaga as a musician. For me she is a singer and artist - showbiz. I would have said the same about Madonna, Tom Jones, Justin Bieber, Michael Jackson, Rihanna.... Michael Jackson and Madonn also wrote some memorable songs.... Paul McCartney I think of as Songwriter, composer, first and foremost... then singer and musician or multi-instrumentalist. A Musician to me I think is someone like Miles Davis, Ravi Shankar, Robert Fripp, Thelonius Monk, Charlie Parker, Robert Wyatt, Rick Wakeman... well, the categories goes on and on and cross over... I'll stop here.
Singer, songwriter, composer, multi-instrumentalist...all are musicians.
Musician/artist, whatever suits your preferences, I was just trying to be a little specific.
-
love2travel:
Hendrix Ibsen:
I find it difficult to think of Lady Gaga as a musician. For me she is a singer and artist - showbiz. I would have said the same about Madonna, Tom Jones, Justin Bieber, Michael Jackson, Rihanna.... Michael Jackson and Madonn also wrote some memorable songs.... Paul McCartney I think of as Songwriter, composer, first and foremost... then singer and musician or multi-instrumentalist. A Musician to me I think is someone like Miles Davis, Ravi Shankar, Robert Fripp, Thelonius Monk, Charlie Parker, Robert Wyatt, Rick Wakeman... well, the categories goes on and on and cross over... I'll stop here.
Yes a composer first and foremost!
Yeah, McCartney is a creator of music.
-
oobu24:
hey_kittay:
^^ I agree with the exception that not only can Lady Gaga sing, but she plays the piano like nobody's business. She has a great, and beautiful voice. Being able to play the piano means she is a musician, which sets her apart from the other artists above, except Paul. I really was so thrilled with her performance last night. She is lovely.
Yes, I agree. I think GaGa is a classically trained pianist.
Well, I guess a classically trained vocalist like Kiri Te Kanawa can also be classified as a musician. What she do with her voice is very technical. To me, Lady Gaga is first and foremost an artist, unless she makes a piano album...
-
Triplets Love Paul:
For those who may be interested:
It's already down. For the first time in my life, I'm looking for a Gaga song online. The power of Paul McCartney is endless.
-
Yep, it is exiting how it will work in a Paul McCartney setting. I can't see the video because of copyright.
-
HaileyMcComet:
Triplets Love Paul:
For those who may be interested:
It's already down. For the first time in my life, I'm looking for a Gaga song online. The power of Paul McCartney is endless.
Here...it is embedded in this article & it is on youtube. Hope you both ^^ can view it.
-
Hendrix Ibsen:
oobu24:
hey_kittay:
^^ I agree with the exception that not only can Lady Gaga sing, but she plays the piano like nobody's business. She has a great, and beautiful voice. Being able to play the piano means she is a musician, which sets her apart from the other artists above, except Paul. I really was so thrilled with her performance last night. She is lovely.
Yes, I agree. I think GaGa is a classically trained pianist.
Well, I guess a classically trained vocalist like Kiri Te Kanawa can also be classified as a musician. What she do with her voice is very technical. To me, Lady Gaga is first and foremost an artist, unless she makes a piano album...
I meant she was trained as a classical pianist & then goes on to do things like Poker Face & others. She is a singer that can play the piano & had a "hook" thus the theatrics.
-
Yeah, okay, then I'm more on the wavelength or what to say... with a limited English vocabualry.
-
Hendrix Ibsen:
Yeah, okay, then I'm more on the wavelength or what to say... with a limited English vocabualry.
You are doing just fine!
-
Thanks!