"Temporary Secretary" live in the studio (by fans)
-
I have shown this video to Paul's band members on twitter, hopefully they will like it and show it to Paul:
It these fans can do a great version live in the studio, can you imagine what it would sound like onstage done by Paul and his band? -
Excellent version! Hope it has some influence on Paul's band.
-
I just love the song. It's just grown so far on me during the decades. I used to think it was so ordinary on first listen. Like, real ordinary. I now love it. It's got so many layers.
-
I used to think this song was the nadir of Paul's career, but I do like the cover version below (which is a different one).
-
Have always loved this song!
-
oobu24:
Have always loved this song!
ME TOO! But only Paul's version....
-
Temporary Secretary ROCKS. Easily my favorite tune on II. I remember my daughter calling me from France last year and telling me she was in a dance club in Paris, and the place exploded when this song came on. From the mouths of babes! So, a song that was over 30 years old had twenty year olds dancing like fools. Sweet!!
-
wingsoverkc:
Temporary Secretary ROCKS. Easily my favorite tune on II. I remember my daughter calling me from France last year and telling me she was in a dance club in Paris, and the place exploded when this song came on. From the mouths of babes! So, a song that was over 30 years old had twenty year olds dancing like fools. Sweet!!
Great story!
-
wingsoverkc:
Temporary Secretary ROCKS. Easily my favorite tune on II. I remember my daughter calling me from France last year and telling me she was in a dance club in Paris, and the place exploded when this song came on. From the mouths of babes! So, a song that was over 30 years old had twenty year olds dancing like fools. Sweet!!
Incidentally, France liked "Ou Est Le Soleil," too. Years ago, my college roommate spent a summer over there and brought back a cassette-recording of a French radio station that played the song twice in one hour.
-
Here's another crazy-ass cover version of this fabulous Paul song:
er, that video's a bit dodgy actually, so discretion advised. -
Squid:
Here's another crazy-ass cover version of this fabulous Paul song:
er, that video's a bit dodgy actually, so discretion advised.I stopped listening after less than a minute. A terrible version of the song. Tries to be provocative with the clip. But nothing escapes the fact it is a horrid cheap imitation. Terrible rendition.
-
Come on, it's not that bad.
-
5th-beatle:
I have shown this video to Paul's band members on twitter, hopefully they will like it and show it to Paul:
It these fans can do a great version live in the studio, can you imagine what it would sound like onstage done by Paul and his band?Not trying to steal your thread but wish you can send them this one ( Dear Boy), think many people would love it.
-
yankeefan7:
5th-beatle:
I have shown this video to Paul's band members on twitter, hopefully they will like it and show it to Paul:
It these fans can do a great version live in the studio, can you imagine what it would sound like onstage done by Paul and his band?Not trying to steal your thread but wish you can send them this one ( Dear Boy), think many people would love it.
I am not normally a fan of covers... but hey, they certainly did not do any disservice to it.... that was pretty good.
-
yankeefan7:
5th-beatle:
I have shown this video to Paul's band members on twitter, hopefully they will like it and show it to Paul:
It these fans can do a great version live in the studio, can you imagine what it would sound like onstage done by Paul and his band?Not trying to steal your thread but wish you can send them this one ( Dear Boy), think many people would love it.
LOVE that one & Pure McCartney does it good!
Ya know...why not send Paul the entire DVD of Pure McCartney? oh yeah! -
oobu24:
yankeefan7:
5th-beatle:
I have shown this video to Paul's band members on twitter, hopefully they will like it and show it to Paul:
It these fans can do a great version live in the studio, can you imagine what it would sound like onstage done by Paul and his band?Not trying to steal your thread but wish you can send them this one ( Dear Boy), think many people would love it.
LOVE that one & Pure McCartney does it good!
Ya know...why not send Paul the entire DVD of Pure McCartney? oh yeah!Amen - lol !!
-
toris:
yankeefan7:
5th-beatle:
I have shown this video to Paul's band members on twitter, hopefully they will like it and show it to Paul:
It these fans can do a great version live in the studio, can you imagine what it would sound like onstage done by Paul and his band?Not trying to steal your thread but wish you can send them this one ( Dear Boy), think many people would love it.
I am not normally a fan of covers... but hey, they certainly did not do any disservice to it.... that was pretty good.
Look up them doing "Back Seat Of My Car", it is really good also !!
-
Here is another one: "Sunshine, Sometime".
-
Very nice cover of "Temporary Secretary". I've always loved the song, the recording... it's more speedily with McCartney, with a synth in your face, but more melodic here, it is good song! Let's play it live... The whole of "McCartney II", with a band...
-
I think this a really good version. Would be interesting to see how Paul would arrange it for his band if performed live.
