Music, Photography
For me it was "I'll Get You" and "Please Please Me" on the 2005 US Tour. That whole show was full of surprises!
Some other rarities that come to mind were "Another Day" and "Good Rockin' Tonight" at the New World Tour concert in '93, and "Venus and Mars/Rock Show" at the Hollywood Bowl in 2010.
But i guess by your "criteria" the only real rarity was Venus and Mars/Rock Show in 2010.
They were still touring at this stage also. Hopefully there will be some live recordings as part of the "Bonus Features"! 
Driving to L.A. soon for tonight's show! Anyone else on the board going to Sofi Stadium to see Paul tonight? Whoooo!
I'll be in Sec. 124! Can't wait!
love2travel wrote:
Was there, not sure if my brother took any video. I’ll have to check with him. It was a great show, wasn’t it. Supposedly no one is further than 400 ft to the stage at the JOINT! I have some great still photos from that trip.
I was there too. It was a fantastic show, and Paul was in top form! I only have some photos and a few video clips I took on my cell phone. I have not seen a full video of this show, but I do have the complete bootleg of the concert on CD. Same cover as somebody posted. Excellent recording!
The Joint is now called The Theater at Virgin Hotels, after Virgin bought the Hard Rock. And now the Hard Rock Hotels just bought The Mirage on the Strip and they are going to build a new hotel there. It's where The Beatles LOVE theater is, so I wonder what is going to happen with their show?
9 Times so far!
Wings Over America - Cow Palace San Francisco June 1976
The New World Tour - Anaheim Stadium April 1993
Driving USA - Oakland Arena April 2002
US Tour - HP Pavilion San Jose CA Nov. 2005
An Evening with Paul McCartney - The Joint at Hard Rock Hotel - Las Vegas Nevada April 19, 2009
Up and Coming Tour - Hollywood Bowl Night 2 - March 31, 2010
Out There Tour - Dodger Stadium Los Angeles CA - Aug. 2014
Out There Tour - Petco Park San Diego CA - Sept. 2014
Freshen Up Tour - Petco Park San Diego CA - June 2019
Also, saw him play with Ringo at The Night That Changed America concert and TV taping - L.A. Convention Center - Los Angeles CA - Jan. 2014 (50th Anniversary of The Beatles on the Ed Sullivan Show)
Dennis Arts wrote:
I know it’s not the most reliable source, but I just saw on facebook a post with a quote from Paul, announcing the release of an album with tracks from the soundchecks from the past years! That is the best idea ever! Realllllly looking forward to that, especially since attending a soundcheck is such a rare happening and you always miss out on some tracks you also really want to hear!
Actually, a lot of the songs on "the Russian album" Choba B CCCP he plays during soundchecks. That was just reissued. Maybe that's what he was referring to?
Thanks for starting this thread. Greatly looking forward to the 50 Anniversary of Abbey Road...and the treasures The Beatles will release for the occasion! 
Renan Takenouchi wrote:
5th-beatle wrote:
Last year the November/December concerts were announced in July, so maybe an announcement can still happen anytime between now and the next couple of months?
There are several European countries that have not seen the "Freshen Up" tour yet, for example.
The post on his Instagram said the show at Dodger Stadium was the end of the tour. So at least for this year, I don't think any more shows will happen.
Paul seems to have slowed down a bit: his pattern used to be more than 30 shows in the year, but he did 18 shows in 2018 and 21 shows in 2019; similar amount in both years, so perhaps it's his new pattern. He has already toured Canada, USA, Japan, South America and 6 countries in Europe. I think Australia is too far way for him to return, since he was there not so long ago.
It's time for the man get some rest and really "freshen up" things for next year.
I compared Paul's setlist from the 2014 Out There concert at Petco Park and the 2019 Freshen Up concert at the same...the only repeats were Nineteen Hundred and Eighty Five, Maybe I'm Amazed, I've Just Seen A Face, Blackbird, Here Today, Queenie Eye, Lady Madonna, Eleanor Rigby, Being For the Benefit of Mr. Kite, Something, Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da, and the finish of set one -
For the encore both shows had Helter Skelter, Golden Slumbers, Carry That Weight, and The End.
Out of 38 songs, there were 20 repeats. And a total of 6 numbers I have never seen him do before. Given that the energy level, the performance, and the production were much better than 5 years ago, it felt pretty "fresh" to me!